Skip to main content

The Neighbors’ Window – Review + Analysis

Couple weeks ago, I started to watch short films on YouTube for inspirations. Fortunately, I stumbled upon this one. The title itself, well, explains the whole theme about this short feature. The Neighbors’ Window is a short film written and directed by Marshall Curry. The premise is about a story of Alli (played by Maria Dizzia), a mother of young children who has grown frustrated with her daily routine and husband (played by Greg Keller). But her life is shaken up when two free-spirited twenty-somethings move in across the street and she discovers that she can see into their apartment. This short film was uploaded on 22 December 2019 on the director’s YouTube channel, and it was scored with some accolades like winning an Oscar for Best Short Film.


The presentation is quite simple. No grandeur storyline or set. Just a simple apartment, two different families, that’s all! I can say that there is nothing astonishing in term of technique. But what makes it interesting is the social message that is really powerful and touching.

Sometimes, we look at the neighbors’ window and see their “perfect” life, and we slowly invested with this kind of situation. The cloud of judgment started to appear. At first, we criticized our neighbors by doing what it seems like to be in happy/joyful moments, but actually we started to be obsessed with them. We tried to do something like spying the neighbors and constantly forgot that we are living our best life, too.

It is actually sad that we live in such condition like this, every single day. We tend to see others’ success without seeing that maybe they have been through hell before those moments or doing some bad deeds that could lead into their own destruction. We always focus on the good view of life and not the bad ones. And we sometimes forget that inside our window, the life could be much better than the neighbors’. The grass may look greener on the other side, but we can make ours greener by watering them.


I know I’m not supposed to give life lessons, but I think this topic is really interesting to discuss, and it is really relatable to our life. We might have a look at the success at the other and be envied with it. We start to compare our life with them and our mind starts playing on things that could have been done in the past so maybe we couldn’t be ended up on this situation. People have different ways in overcoming problems and in obtaining success. If maybe we look at the positive side of it, just to make us feel more inspired to do things, that’s fine. But if it ends up finally judging ourselves for not doing enough and feel useless, gotta better stop. Stop killing ourselves by making self-comparisons, because comparison itself the real thief of joy. Things take times. We have the full control of our own happiness, not other people.

Damn, I almost forgot that I’m supposed to review this film.

The performances of the actors are really great, they successfully portrayed the emotions of people who envied to their neighbor. The presentation is pretty simple. The plot is predictable, but the message of this film is delivered very well. it’s not necessarily one of the best short films I’ve seen. Don’t get me wrong, it is actually a good short film with strong messages. It is still enjoyable to watch in free time.
Here is the link if you want to watch it:

Written, directed & edited by: Marshall Curry
Starring: Maria Dizzia, Greg Keller, and Juliana Canfield
Produced by: Jonathan Olson & Julia Kennelly
Executive Produced by: Elizabeth Martin
Director of Photography: Wolfgang Held
Music by: James Baxter & The National



Comments